Isaiah Fountain

People
Written By Sarah Kilmon

Isaiah Fountain: A Forgotten Case of Jim Crow Injustice

Isaiah Fountain was a bold and resourceful African American farmer from Trappe who became the central figure in one of the biggest news stories to occur in Talbot County. In 1919 the Easton Star-Democrat wrote that the Isaiah Fountain case was "one of the most noted in the State's annals." A century later, lawyer and author, Sherrilyn Ifill wrote that the Fountain case "was one of the most notorious on the [Eastern] Shore during the early part of the twentieth century. Ifill also wrote that the case also involved Talbot County's largest incident of mob violence in its history. Today Isaiah Fountain's case is little known.

In the early 20th century, amidst the backdrop of World War I and the Spanish flu pandemic, the United States grappled with heightened economic and racial tensions. The Eastern Shore of Maryland was no exception, becoming the stage for a tragic episode of racial injustice centered around Isaiah Fountain, a successful Black farmer from Trappe, Maryland.

A Fateful Journey

In April 1919, Fountain embarked on a journey from his home in Williamsburg to Easton, the county seat of Talbot County, in search of his wife, who had gone missing after a trip to withdraw money from their bank. Upon discovering that she had completed the transaction but left their horse and wagon behind, he suspected she had traveled to her parents' home in Camden, New Jersey. Fountain followed her there, and she agreed to return home in a week. Unbeknownst to him, this personal matter would intertwine disastrously with events unfolding back in Talbot County.

Accusation and Arrest

On the same afternoon that Fountain was in Easton searching for his wife, a teenage White girl near Trappe reported being raped by a Black man. The coincidence of timing led authorities to suspect Fountain, despite his presence elsewhere. He was swiftly arrested, and his ordeal through the Jim Crow justice system began.

A mug shot and reward advertisement appeared in various newspapers during the massive dragnet for Isaiah Fountain. Note that the caption states that Fountain must be “surrendered to the court alive” in order for the person who captures him to qualify for the reward. (Baltimore Sun/Newspapers.com)

Trials and Escapes

Fountain's first trial was marked by a nine-minute deliberation by an all-White jury, resulting in a conviction. Despite testimonies from three reputable White witnesses, including Easton's Chief of Police, confirming his alibi, Fountain faced relentless pursuit by the legal system. He narrowly escaped lynching by angry mobs and managed to escape custody twice, evading massive manhunts before being recaptured. His appeals led to a retrial, but the outcome remained unchanged.

Execution and Legacy

In July 1920, Isaiah Fountain became the last person to be legally executed on Maryland's Eastern Shore, hanged on a custom-built gallows inside the Talbot County jail. His case, once sensationalized, faded from public memory over the decades. However, recent scholarly work has resurrected his story, shedding light on this dark chapter of racial injustice.

Resurgence of Interest

Author Joseph Koper's book, The Isaiah Fountain Case: Outrage and Jim Crow Justice on Maryland's Eastern Shore, offers a meticulous account of Fountain's ordeal, drawing from media coverage and court records of the time. Koper's research provides a comprehensive look into the systemic failures and racial prejudices that led to Fountain's unjust execution. The book has been recognized for its contribution to regional history, earning the 2023 Gold Medal for Best Regional Non-Fiction Book (Mid-Atlantic) in the Independent Publisher Book Awards.

The Isaiah Fountain Case and Jim Crow’s Eastern Shore: A Chat with Author Joseph Koper

Reflecting on the Past

The resurgence of interest in Isaiah Fountain's case serves as a poignant reminder of the racial injustices prevalent during the Jim Crow era. It prompts reflection on how far society has come and the work that remains in addressing systemic racism. Engaging with such historical accounts is crucial in understanding and rectifying the enduring impacts of past injustices.

Isaiah Fountain's story, once buried in the annals of history, now stands as a testament to the resilience of those who suffered under an unjust system and the importance of continual vigilance in the pursuit of justice.

For those interested in diving deeper into Isaiah Fountain's story, here are some resources:

Sarah Kilmon
Previous

Amelia B. Coppuck Welby
Next

The story of Nathaniel Nace Hopkins